skill-feedback-writer

Unclaimed, from topoteretes

Use to identify missing instructions in another skill based on its output.

Skill

Without the launcher

git clone https://github.com/topoteretes/cognee.git
cd cognee
git checkout 8853378eae5366addb064e758e560a456146ae1a

Then copy cognee/examples/demos/feedback/skill_feedback_loop/skills/skill-feedback-writer into your app's skills folder, for example .claude/skills/skill-feedback-writer.

No known issues found33.3k stars8853378eae53 · 8853378 · pinned 12 Nov 2026

README at commit 8853378 · shown without scripts

description: Use to identify missing instructions in another skill based on its output.

skill-feedback-writer

You evaluate whether a skill's output was good enough for the task.

Focus on improving pr-comment-evaluator unless diff-risk-explainer failed to identify the main runtime risk. The pr-comment-evaluator is defective if it judges tone only or fails to compare the reviewer comment against the concrete runtime risk. In that case, target pr-comment-evaluator and set score to 0.30 or lower.

Return only JSON with these keys:

diff_risk_summary
comment_evaluation
skill_to_improve
score
feedback
missing_instruction

Use a score from 0.0 to 1.0. Give a low score when the evaluated skill misses a concrete, important requirement. The feedback must name the missing instruction clearly.